Skip to main content

why hanging Bhagat Singh was a right decision.

 Bhagat Singh is my role model for his dedication to country, but still i support hanging of  Bhagat Singh.


Bhagat singh killed a british officer named Saunders to revenge the death of lala lajpat rai.

event cronology

30 oct 1928: lathi charge order by british officer scott.

17 nov 1928: lala lajpt rai died at the age of 73 due to heart attack after 18 days of lathi charge.

the doctor gave the statement that lala lajapat rai got heart attack because of lathi charge.

  a very unscientific statement enough to incite the young blooded 21 year old bhagat singh.

now lets have a look on other fact.

scott only ordered lathi charge but the lathi charge was done by lower rank police mainly Indians. 

also scott didn't mentioned the way to charge lathi. it was individual lathi chargers decision whether to strike lathi on head, chest or leg. 

so no one can say that scott was completely responsible for getting strike of lathi on head.


 bhagat singh got completely blinded by feeling of revenge and decided to kill scott. but mistakenly bhagat singh kill Saunders.


bhagat singh killed someone who has nothing to do with even lathi charge.

and the grave mistake was that HSRA published a pamphlet with a message that they took revenge of lala lajpat rai by killing Saunders. 

how killing an innocent justify anyone's revenge.

i don't know about Saunders family but what if Saunders had small children in his family. 

killing Saunders made them orphaned. 

  so no doubt bhagat singh was a great patriot but he deserved to be hanged for his mistakes.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Archadian

Every Archadian were looking towards the sky in the hope of sunset and with every passing moment they were afraid of lose. Their fear made them more weak and they lost more life in battle field in-front of large Valvan army. The field was full of blood surrounded by hill on one side and forests from another side. Rest of the two sides covered with two army in front of each other. Archadian vs Valvan The Valvan get more aggressive with their swords flying in the battle field. Finally with sunset, drum sound spread all over the field and war was at end. With sunset over the hills, darkness spread in the field and blood became more red in absence of sun. Alkan, the arrogant Valavn king, ask his solider to return back to tent leaving behind injured and dead Valvan solider in field. Both the army headed towards their tent leaving blood on the earth of Archadians. The Valvan get busy in celebrating their victory in today's battle field. While in Archadian tent, king Arithm order a
Post a Comment
Read more

Women Personality in Pre Independence Era

  Women Personality in Pre Independence Era Rani Velu Nachiyar(1730-1796)-  She was the first Indian queen(Sivaganga estate) to wage war with the East India Company in India. She regained her kingdom after defeating EICo. with the help of Hyder Ali and many mores. In Tamil she is regarded as Veeramangai .  She was a scholar of French, English, and Urdu languages. Savitribai Phule(1831-1897)-  She raised her voice against caste and gender discrimination. In 1848 she started school in Pune for girl education. She died while serving the Plague affected people.  Pandita Ramabai Sarasvati(1858-1922)-  1st woman to be awarded the titles of Pandita as a Sanskrit scholar and Sarasvati after being examined by the faculty of the University of Calcutta. In 1882, she presented the issue of women education to Hunter Commission . She founded Arya Mahila Samaj(Pune, 1882) . In the same year she wrote Stri Dharma Niti(Morals for Women) book and in 1883 she moved to Britain where she embraced Christia
Post a Comment
Read more

Surveys in India

  Surveys in India 1. National Family Health Survey 2020-21(NFHS-5) Year 2023 Sex ratio- 1020 Rural sex ratio- 1037 Urban sex ratio- 985 State having highest sex ratio- Kerala(sex ratio- 1084)  Sex ratio at birth- 933 4 types of sex ratios according to the stages of development. Primary Sex Ratio- Sex ratio at Fertilization Secondary Sex Ratio- Sex ratio at Birth  Tertiary Sex Ratio- Sex ratio at maturity Quaternary Sex Ratio- Sex ratio above the age of 60 years 
Post a Comment
Read more